Concrete falls apart from the inside because a large share of its own binder is a
compound that carries no load and dissolves easily. When cement hydrates it leaves
calcium hydroxide, also called portlandite, as a by-product. Benjamin Cook, Zirconia’s
founder, puts it at 20 to 25 percent of the cement, and Zirconia’s chemistry reference
puts the leftover at roughly 20 percent of the cement mass. Either way, about a fifth of the
binder holding a structure together is soluble and chemically reactive rather than
structural. It is what carbonation consumes, what acid dissolves, what soft water leaches
out, and what wear removes first. Convert it into a durable binder and the mechanisms that
depend on it lose the thing they feed on.
Why cement makes calcium hydroxide in the first place
Portland cement does not turn entirely into the phase that does the work. The hydration
reaction that builds calcium silicate hydrate, the binder written as C-S-H, also produces
calcium hydroxide alongside it. That is inherent to how cement cures, not a sign of a bad
mix or a bad pour. It is present in sound, well placed, correctly cured concrete.
This is also why the paste, rather than the aggregate, decides how long a structure lasts.
Aggregate is comparatively dense and inert. The paste carries both the capillary pore
network and the weakest phase in the matrix, and those two things sit next to each other:
the pores deliver water and everything dissolved in it straight to the compound least able
to resist it.
Why a fifth of the binder doing no work is the whole problem
Calcium hydroxide is not inert filler quietly taking up space. It is the most chemically
available part of the matrix, and that makes it the point of entry rather than a passenger.
Three properties do the damage.
- It is soluble. Water moving through the pore network carries calcium out
of the binder, and what is left behind is a weaker, silica-rich gel.
- It is reactive. Carbon dioxide and acids react with it preferentially, so
it is the compound that gets consumed while the rest of the matrix is still intact.
- It is soft. On an untreated surface, the portlandite-rich paste is the
weakest phase, so abrasion takes the vulnerable material first and exposes more of it.
Each of those ends the same way. Wherever calcium hydroxide is consumed or washed out, it
leaves a void, and that void widens the pore network which delivered the attack. Damaged
paste is more porous than sound paste, so every round of damage opens the path for the next.
Concrete deterioration accelerates rather than progressing steadily, and this compound is
the reason why.
The six forms of corrosion that lead back to one compound
Benjamin Cook counts six separate forms of corrosion that trace back to calcium hydroxide.
They look like six different problems on a condition survey. Chemically they are six
different aggressors arriving at the same target.
1. Carbonation
Carbon dioxide diffuses in and reacts with calcium hydroxide, decalcifying the binder and
dropping pore pH from about 12.5 to below 9. Below that point the passive oxide film that
protects embedded steel dissolves, and reinforcement corrosion begins.
2. Chloride attack
Free calcium hydroxide leaves the paste with a net positive surface charge, which draws
negatively charged chloride ions inward. Untreated concrete also lacks the aluminate sites
needed to lock chloride away, so it travels through the pore solution to the steel.
3. Microbial acid attack
In sewers and wastewater structures, bacteria convert hydrogen sulfide into sulfuric acid.
That acid attacks calcium hydroxide and the binder, releasing gypsum and silica gel and
opening the surface further with every cycle.
4. Leaching and decalcification
Soft water, carbonation and acid all pull calcium out of the binder. Bridging bonds
hydrolyze, interlayer water is lost, and what remains is a silica-rich gel with a fraction
of the cohesion the original binder had.
5. Abrasion and wear
Wear removes the weakest phase first, and on untreated concrete the weakest phase is the
portlandite-rich paste at the surface. The wear face is the vulnerable material rather
than the durable one.
6. Freeze-thaw
Pore water expands about 9 percent when it freezes. Every void that leaching and
carbonation open makes room for more freezable water, so each winter cycle cracks a
slightly weaker, slightly wetter matrix than the one before.
Read that list as one mechanism rather than six. Carbonation, chloride attack, acid, wear
and freeze-thaw are different aggressors, but they converge on the same soluble, reactive,
load-free compound, and each one leaves the concrete more open than it found it. That is the
useful way to think about it: treating the symptom means chasing six problems, and treating
the cause means changing what the concrete is made of.